Copyright

Newsletter

View Housing Market Watch RSS feed

What Median Home Prices Would Look Like If the Bubble Never Happened

Jan 28, 2008

What price should you be paying for a home? It's easy to calculate if you can see how median home prices and median incomes correlate.

Request a
Free Quote

Historically, median home prices and median incomes have shared a close relationship. From the mid-1970s to 2001, the ratio of median housing value vs. median household income consistently stayed between 2.6 and 3.0.

What this essentially means is that median home prices averaged 2.8x the median household income over the last 30 years. Using this 2.8 formula, it 's easy to estimate what the median home prices would be if the recent housing bubble had never happened.

U.S. Median Home Prices

Current Median Price* What the Median Price Ought to Be % Difference
$208,400 $134,692 35%

Median household income information for 2007 is not yet available, so we will be using median household income data for 2006 in this example and in the following examples. This shouldn't make that much difference since household incomes increased at most by 4 percent (and that's a very generous estimate) in 2007.

The median U.S. household income is $48,201, according to the Census Bureau. When we multiply this number by 2.8, we get $134,692. That's what the U.S. median home price ought to be right now. The actual median home price, however is about 35 percent higher that that.

Median Home Prices by Region

Region Current Median Price* What the Median Price Ought to Be % Difference
Northeast $258,600 $145,760 44%
Midwest $159,800 $133,941 16%
South $173,400 $122,875 29%
West $309,800 $146,297 53%

It is obvious to most people that we're in the middle of a nationwide housing bubble. Nevertheless, there are still naysayers telling us that there are local bubbles only.

Using the 2.8 formula, it is clear that local bubbles aren't the problem. Median home prices show inflation in every U.S. region. In the West, with a median household income of $52,249, median home prices are more than double what they should be. There is a similar situation in the Northeast, where the median household income is $52,057.

Median home prices are somewhat lower in the South and Midwest, with median household incomes of $43,884 and $47,836 respectively. Even so, prices are still 30 percent above where they should be in the South and 16 percent above what they should be in the Midwest.

California Median Home Prices

Current Median Price* What the Median Price Ought to Be % Difference
$402,000 $158,606 61%

There is no doubt about it. California was the state that was hit the hardest by the housing bubble. Although California's prices have always been slightly elevated, they grew by great leaps and bounds during the housing boom.

The result is that home prices are 61 percent above where they should be given California's median household income of $56,645. In certain areas, such as Oakland and San Francisco, median home prices are so inflated that they are over 11 times the median household income.

Will Home Prices Fall?

Absolutely. Prices have already fallen by six percent nationwide and over 11 percent in the West in a year-by-year comparison. Home prices must continue to fall in order for the average American to afford a home.

The real question is: how long will it take?

The U.S. government seems to be doing everything it can to prop up prices. Before you applaud these efforts, it's worth noting that while their quick-fix methods could work in the short term, all they will really do is to ensure that we have a slow fall.

The truth is that propping up prices and thus prolonging the correction will not solve anything. The Japan Ministry tried this same scheme during the Japan correction and it was a complete disaster.

All we can really do now is to prepare for the fall. It will come and when it does, it's going to hurt. But that's the price that must be paid for allowing the market to become artificially inflated.


*Current median price refers to median prices of existing homes as of December 2007. Current median figures were obtained from the National Association of Realtors' EHS data.

Related Articles

Fed Report Shows Americans Have Less Home Equity Than Ever Before

Falling prices are eroding the value of U.S. homes. According to a new Fed report, the equity that Americans have in their homes has dropped to the lowest level on record.

Survey Says Most Renters Won't Buy a Home

A survey commissioned by a national federation of state and local apartment associations shows that most renters will not be jumping into the U.S. housing market anytime soon. Has renting become the smart decision?

What the American People Think About a Mortgage Bailout

Some politicians are in favor of providing assistance to the millions of homeowners who are facing default as a result of poor decision-making and falling home prices. Others are dead set against it. Let's see where the American people stand.

What Will Happen to Your Money When Your Bank Fails

Small banks and big ones alike are on the verge of bankruptcy, due to all of the bad loans that have been approved over the past few years. Although people tend to assume that their money will be safe even if their banks fail, history has shown that this isn't always the case. Find out if your hard-earned cash is at risk.

A Comparison of U.S. Home Prices

When it comes to home prices, location matters. Consider this: a $210,000 home in Atlanta, GA would be worth $1.4 million in Beverly Hills. The same home would be worth $509,000 in Washington D.C. and $207,000 in Phoenix. Find out how much homes might be worth in different cities in this home price comparison.

Three Reasons Why a Mortgage Bailout Is a Terrible Idea

An open letter to all of the lawmakers and taxpayers who think a mortgage bailout is what we need to solve the housing crisis.

Most Expensive Cities and States to Rent a Two-Bedroom Apartment

A national survey found that Stamford, Connecticut has most expensive rents among other U.S. cities. Residents need a household wage of $31.58 to afford fair market rent on a two-bedroom rental unit. Find out which other metro areas and states have high housing costs.

Lenders Giving Mortgage Borrowers Cash for Keys

To get borrowers to leave a house--and leave it in good condition--mortgage lenders around the nation have begun offering cash for keys. Some lenders are paying out upwards of $3,000.

New Foreclosure Prevention Legislation Designed to Bail Out Big Business

Republicans and Democrats are working on a new measure inappropriately named ''The Foreclosure Prevention Act of 2008''. This legislation is being billed as help for homeowners, but homebuilders and the mortgage industry are the true beneficiaries.